Buying guides

Best mattress firmness for every sleeping position

How you sleep decides where your body needs give and where it needs holding up. Get the firmness right and your spine stays roughly straight all night. Get it wrong and you wake up stiff, however good the mattress is. Here's how we match firmness to sleeping position on the shop floor, with the beds we'd point you to for each.

Quick answer

  • Side sleepers: soft to medium. Your shoulders and hips need to sink in.
  • Back sleepers: medium-firm to firm. Your lower back needs holding up.
  • Stomach sleepers: medium to medium-firm. Firm enough that your hips don't drop, not so firm that they lift.
  • Mixed sleepers: medium or medium-firm.
  • Heavier than average? Go one step firmer. Lighter? One step softer.
  • Whatever the guide says, lie on it for ten minutes in store before you decide.

Firmness is how a mattress feels, not how well it supports you

People use "firm" to mean "supportive". They're different things. Support comes from the spring unit in the middle of the mattress: on our beds that's a Contour-Flex continuous coil, a Therawrap pocket spring or an Innergy independent coil. Firmness comes from the comfort layers on top: foam, wool, latex, pillow tops. A soft mattress built on a good spring unit will support you properly. A firm mattress with a tired spring unit won't.

So when you're choosing, you're really choosing how much cushioning you want between you and the springs. That depends on your sleeping position and your weight.

Side sleepers: soft to medium

On your side, all your weight goes through two points: a shoulder and a hip. If the surface is too firm those points take the pressure, you fold at the waist, and your spine curves. You want enough give for the shoulder and hip to sink so your spine stays level.

Beds we'd try first:

  • Sense-A-Tech Plush: medium-soft, with a deep box top over a continuous coil. 260 mm deep, from $549 (Single, mattress only). Our best-value soft bed.
  • Posture Plus: soft, with a wool-blend gusset top on both sides, so you can flip it. 255 mm, from $769.
  • Windsor Latex: medium-soft, with a thick latex and wool pillow top over an Innergy coil and HourGlass lumbar support. 335 mm, from $1,649. The one to try if you sleep on your side but still get a sore back.

Browse the full soft mattress range.

Back sleepers: medium-firm to firm

On your back your weight spreads out, and the job is to stop your hips sinking lower than your shoulders. Too soft and you end up in a shallow hammock with your lower back arched. Medium-firm is where most back sleepers land; go firm if you like a flat, solid feel.

  • Anniversary Pocket: medium-firm, a 3-zone pocket spring with firmer springs through the middle for your lower back. 280 mm, from $549. Our entry pocket spring and a best seller.
  • Windsor Backcare: medium-firm, with Therapedic's HourGlass back support through the lumbar zone and a two-sided build you can flip. 335 mm, from $1,539.
  • Opulence: firm, with a pocket spring unit, Viscoool open-cell foam and a wool pillow top. 310 mm, from $1,199. Also the mattress we recommend if you're keeping an existing base.

See the medium and firm ranges.

Stomach sleepers: medium to medium-firm

This is where we part company with most of the internet, which tells stomach sleepers to buy the firmest bed they can find. On your front the risk is your hips sinking and your back arching, so you do need support. But on a very firm surface your hips sit up and your spine bows the other way, and you'll wake with a sore lower back and neck just the same. In our experience medium to medium-firm is the sweet spot: enough support under the hips, a little give for the ribs.

  • Citation Box Top: medium-firm on the wool-top side; flip it over for a slightly firmer feel without the wool. Innergy coil, Triple Edge wire. 260 mm, from $989.
  • Spinal Luxury G-Top: medium-firm, a 5-zone pocket spring with a latex gusset top. 300 mm, from $989.
  • Monarch: medium-firm, double-sided, on a continuous coil. 220 mm, from $659. A sensible choice for a spare room that gets a lot of use.

If you move around all night

Most people do: two to four position changes an hour is normal. If you have no main position, a medium or medium-firm mattress is the safe middle. If you spend most of the night in one position and the rest elsewhere, buy for the main one. The Anniversary Pocket and Spinal Luxury G-Top both suit mixed sleepers well.

Your weight shifts the answer

Two people can lie on the same mattress and feel two different beds. A heavier person sinks further into the comfort layers, so a "medium" feels soft to them; a lighter person barely dents it, so the same bed feels firm. As a rule, if you're well above average weight go one step firmer than the guide above, and if you're well below it go one step softer.

When you and your partner disagree

Two things help. A pocket spring mattress (anything in our Therawrap range) lets each side respond to the person on it, so a firmer-preferring partner isn't bounced around by a softer-preferring one. And on a King or Super King you can have a twin set: two mattresses side by side on one base, each in its own firmness. Ask in store; it's a common request.

How to test a mattress properly

Lie on it for ten minutes, in the position you actually sleep in, with your partner if you share. Sitting on the edge tells you nothing. If you're on your side, check your shoulder and hip have settled in and your waist is supported. On your back, slide a hand under the small of your back: a little room is right, a big gap means it's too firm, no room at all means it's too soft.

And if you get it wrong at home, our 100 Nights Customer Satisfaction Guarantee lets you exchange the mattress for a different feel. Conditions apply: it needs to come back clean, and custom sizes are excluded.

Frequently asked questions

Is a firm mattress better for back sleepers?
Medium-firm suits most back sleepers. Go firm if you prefer a flat, solid feel. The key is that your hips don't sink lower than your shoulders.

What firmness is best for side sleepers?
Soft to medium, so your shoulder and hip can sink in and your spine stays level.

Should stomach sleepers buy a firm mattress?
Not necessarily. Medium to medium-firm keeps your hips supported without arching your back the other way.

Does body weight change which firmness I need?
Yes. Heavier sleepers sink further and usually need one step firmer; lighter sleepers one step softer.

How do I know my mattress is too firm?
Pressure or numbness in your shoulders or hips, or a gap under your lower back when you lie flat.

Still not sure?

Take the two-minute Bed Selector and it will shortlist beds for your position and budget. Or come in for a test nap at any of our stores; our sleep specialists do this all day.

Related guides: Buying a new bed: the complete guide · NZ mattress sizes · 3-zone vs 5-zone mattresses · What makes a mattress and bed base compatible

Back to blog